US bank run has slowed to a walk, but instability remains

The Australian
David Rogers
October 23, 2023

Ravi Chopra's Azora Capital had its best month in March when it shorted the US banks that failed. Picture: Jaclyn Licht

When Ravi Chopra reveals his stock pick at the prestigious Sohn Hearts & Minds conference at the Opera House in Sydney next month, it could well be a short bet on a US bank.

 

When Ravi Chopra reveals his stock pick at the prestigious Sohn Hearts & Minds conference at the Opera House in Sydney on November 17, it could well be a short bet on a US bank.

 

Chopra is the chief investment office and founder of Azora Capital, a long-short hedge fund investing only in US financial services companies. As the US 10-year Treasury yield soars to 5 per cent, he says the interest rate and liquidity risk that caused the regional banking crisis in March is still out there.

 

He started out as an investment banking analyst at Goldman Sachs during the tech wreck, before working as a financial services analyst at Sigma Capital, a subsidiary of Steve Cohen’s SAC Capital Advisers.

 

In the global financial crisis he was a partner and sector head of financial services at Sigma offshoot Samlyn Capital.

 

His most profitable times as a fund manager have been during crises – the GFC, the coronavirus crash of March 2020, and the US regional banking crisis of March this year.

 

Azora had its best year ever in 2020 when US interest rates were cut to the lowest level in history.

 

March 2023 was its best month ever – Azora was short each of the four banks that failed.

 

A full year before the US regional bank failures of 2023, Chopra warned of the “tragic positioning” of some banks in terms of their investment portfolios, concluding there was “no way out”. Swift action by the Fed saved the day back then, but the warnings are still flashing red.

 

Chopra explains that the GFC stemmed from poorly underwritten credit and credit losses that dwarfed bank capital. So for the past 15 years, bank management teams, rating agencies and regulators have been stress-testing for credit and capital.

But they underestimated the interest rate and liquidity risks from pandemic-era monetary policy.

 

Unlike the GFC, where credit losses dominated, losses stemming from interest rate risk mismanagement in the current cycle will end up dwarfing losses from credit risk, Chopra says.

 

It started when the Fed slashed its funds rate from 2.5 per cent to zero in March 2022 and began a $US5 trillion quantitative easing program, lowering the 10-year Treasury bond yield to a record low of 32 basis points, and effectively pushing $US5 trillion on to bank balance sheets.

 

Typically, the US banking industry sees steady deposit growth of about 6 per cent per annum.

 

But in 2021, deposits leapt by an unheard of 35 per cent, most of it non-interest bearing deposits.

 

Some banks hoovered up a disproportionate share of those deposits.

 

They were typically in growth industries like technology, biotechnology and cryptocurrency.

 

Thanks to the massive growth in deposits, they experienced huge share price growth.

 

Some bank’s “carry trades” in 1 to 1.5 per cent yielding securities with 10-year maturities, funded by zero-cost non-interest-bearing deposits, were multiples of the size of the existing banks in 2019.

 

Then the Fed raised interest rates at the fastest pace since the 1970s and started quantitative tightening that wiped $US700bn off the value of the banking industry’s fixed-rate assets.

 

That was about 60 per cent of the capital base of the entire banking industry, which was similar to the peak of the GFC in terms of credit losses as a percentage of capital in the US banking industry.

 

Higher interest rates also make it hard for some banks to keep funding their deposits.

 

Azora’s analysis, marking-to-market bank balance sheets for the new interest rate environment and the unrealised losses of bond portfolios, found many banks were undercapitalised. Some were mathematically insolvent. It also looked at liquidity risks, using the percentage of each bank’s deposits that were uninsured, to come up with its list of short selling targets.

 

But Chopra still worries about the “recency bias” of financial institutions and regulators amid a structural shift to higher inflation and interest rates after a long period of falling inflation and rates.

 

“We’ve been conditioned since the GFC to think that anytime the economy sneezed, anytime there was trouble in the world, the Fed was going to cut rates and buy bonds,” he says. “It was inconceivable to think that just two years after a global pandemic that we’ve never seen in our lives, the Fed could be raising interest rates 500 basis points.”

 

He also notes that while the Fed’s Bank Term Funding facility allowed banks to post assets as collateral at face value in exchange for funding, legislative difficulties prevented regulators from guaranteeing deposits in excess of the $US250,000 limit as they did in the GFC.

 

“That was the ‘ah ha’ moment for depositors,” Chopra says.

 

“For the first time perhaps, depositors realised they were actually unsecured lenders to these banks, and they weren’t even getting paid for it.”

 

The day after the Fed’s BTF facility was announced, some banks’ share prices fell 30-50 per cent.

 

Bank “runs” have stopped, but bank “walks” continue, as the regional banking crisis showed depositors they were taking on an intended credit risk for no return,

 

They’re shifting to mutual funds paying 5.5 per cent risk free.

 

“To be clear, if you have zero-cost funding that’s leaving, you now have to replace that with market-rate funding. Market-rate funding could now cost you 5.5 to 6 per cent,” Chopra says.

 

Free money leaving and 6 per cent coming in is a big problem for the banks. He also worries that US interest rates will continue to rise, worsening unrealised losses on bond portfolios, pushing banks to use “break glass in emergency” funding to pay their depositors.

 

“They can cut their dividends, or raise equity capital, but no financial institution wants to go down that route – a dividend cut is a really negative signal, and a capital raise is what precipitated the failure of Silicon Valley Bank – no one wants to be the guinea pig to try that right now.”

 

He says to the extent that banks are looking to scale back their lending to improve their capital ratios, it will tighten their underwriting standards and weaken their loan growth. With that comes rising loan losses, because as liquidity leaves the system, it’s harder to get a loan.

 

“Credit bubbles start popping, and one area is commercial real estate,” Chopra says.

 

“Sixty per cent of all commercial real estate loans are made by the banking system, two-thirds of those are made by the smallest banks, where some of the issues are the most acute. That has led to a near complete dry-up of liquidity in certain areas of the commercial real estate market, particularly the office market, which portends greater losses to come from credit.”

 

Sohn Hearts & Minds delivers stock picks from investment experts around the globe, with all profits raised going to medical research. The conference is on track to raise $60m by November.

 

The Australian is a media partner of Sohn Hearts and Minds. Information and tickets can be found here.

This article was originally posted by The Australian here.

Licensed by Copyright Agency. You must not copy this work without permission.

More Insights & Media

Grounds, Fowler, and Weiss set up the Australian version, the Sohn Hearts & Minds conference in 2016, with the first meeting at the Sydney Opera House.
January 25, 2024
Fowler toasts Sohn legacy

It might be time to look beyond big name, overpriced Wall Street stocks that could struggle to deliver growth. That was the message from top fund managers, company founders and super funds at the Sohn Hearts & Minds Conference.
November 17, 2023
The 12 hottest stock tips from this year’s Sohn experts

The US financial sector is not without its problems but Ravi Chopra backs Webster Financial Corporation as his stock pick for the 2023 Sohn Hearts & Minds Investment Leaders Conference.
November 17, 2023
Webster Financial ‘avoided the mistakes of US bank failures’

When Damian Lewis, the actor who plays the ruthless hedge fund boss in the drama series Billions was looking for inspiration, he sat down with Daniel Loeb.
November 17, 2023
How Daniel Loeb, the real Bobby Axelrod, made his Wall Street billions

Speaking at the Sohn Hearts & Minds conference on Friday, the Future Fund’s chief investment officer Ben Samild said it had traded around $65 billion worth of its portfolio for assets with better protection against what is expected to be a long-term inflationary environment.
November 17, 2023
Cash is king, even for professional investors

Tech investment guru Cathie Wood is still a big believer in bitcoin, so it was fitting that she chose Grayscale Bitcoin Trust as her stock pick for the 2023 Sohn Hearts & Minds Investment Leaders Conference.
November 17, 2023
ARK founder Wood backs bitcoin, banking on spot ETF approval

Cathie Wood has rightly called several of the big themes driving markets this year. But the world’s most divisive investor says we’re thinking about AI in the wrong way.
November 17, 2023
‘I know it sounds crazy’: Cathie Wood’s next big idea

The world’s highest-profile tech investor, Cathie Wood, might be bruised but she is certainly bullish. Nor is she holding back. “I have always hated searching on Google,” she says of the search giant.
November 17, 2023
Why stock picker Cathie Wood of ARK can’t stand Google

Institutional investors such as super and pension funds are investing in private equity at “exactly the wrong time”, a top hedge fund manager has warned, as sharply higher interest rates threaten a wave of bankruptcies.
November 17, 2023
Investors sound warning on private equity timebomb

Munro Partners partner Kieran Moore believes London-listed money transfer company Wise could see its share price soar 50 per cent by 2025, as its problem-solving business model gains traction while benefiting from higher interest rates.
November 17, 2023
Wise share price could rise 50pc by 2025, says Munro Partners

Healthcare stocks – from sleep apnoea giant ResMed, to cancer diagnostic biotech Telix Pharmaceuticals – were recommended at the Sohn Hearts & Minds Investment Leaders Conference on Friday.
November 17, 2023
Hot stocks to ride the next healthcare trends

Bryce and Ren from Equity Mates are joined by Ashish Swarup is a Portfolio Manager and Investment Analyst at Aikya Investment Management
November 16, 2023
Ashish Swarup - Invest in snacks, let's get that bread | Aikya Investment Management

Most hedge fund managers brag about their wins and shy away from their losses – Martin Hughes is not most hedge fund managers.
November 16, 2023
Hedge fund veteran talks lowest moment in Toscafund’s 23-year run

The Future Fund, Australia’s $200 billion sovereign wealth fund, has been sounding the alarm on the developed world’s rising levels of debt, the prospect of higher inflation, and the risks in the bond market for longer than most.
November 16, 2023
The ‘Armageddon scenario’ worrying the Future Fund CIO

A year on from the start of ChatGPT, the Future Fund hasn’t decided how to play this phase of the AI revolution but is open to the possibility it will be a major boost to productivity.
November 16, 2023
Future Fund weighs up AI productivity riddle

When genomic scientist Daniel MacArthur had the opportunity to set up a new Centre for Population Genomics in Australia in 2019, he jumped at the chance to return home after 12 years living overseas.
November 15, 2023
Advancing medicine is in Daniel MacArthur’s DNA

Daniel Loeb of Third Point says the way companies are dealing with the high cost of debt is delivering new opportunities.
November 15, 2023
Daniel Loeb’s Wall St hedge fund Third Point raises bets on corporate credit crunch

Australia’s best stock pickers have just eight minutes to convince the country’s top money managers they have found an investment gem that the market has overlooked.
November 15, 2023
Five secrets to delivering the perfect pitch

Australia’s best stock pickers have just eight minutes to convince the country’s top money managers they have found an investment gem that the market has overlooked.

Mining stocks are poised to rise amid tight supply for key commodities such as copper, nickel and uranium, says Terra Capital founder Jeremy Bond.
November 13, 2023
Bond bullish on commodity stocks, uranium

European leisure and luxury – a designer handbag, a last-minute flight to Monte Carlo, a stay in a five-star hotel – is where many choose to spend their hard-earned cash. For Sharif el Khazen, it’s where he makes it.
November 13, 2023
This hedge fund manager is making a 100-year bet on luxury

Global growth fund manager Munro Partners will have a difficult task choosing a single company to tip to an audience of industry heavyweights at the Sohn Hearts & Minds conference.
November 12, 2023
How Munro will pick its next stock winner

The culture at Ray Dalio’s massive hedge fund has been a source of intrigue, and with a new book, controversy. Atul Lele says it’s made him a better investor.
November 12, 2023
The Australian at the centre of Dalio’s Bridgewater – who loves it

Melbourne scientist Misty Jenkins has had a long-time interest in immunology. But it was a neuroscientist friend who urged her to focus her skills on seeking a cure for brain ­cancer.
November 10, 2023
Big thinkers in hunt for brain cancer cure

Sheila Patel says it’s time for the venture capital sector to “grow up” and higher rates will help do that. VC firms need to think differently about how they invest.
November 10, 2023
Meet the Goldman Sachs legend shaking up venture capital

Tom Naughton is Managing Partner and CIO at Prusik Investment and speak with Equity Mates ahead of his appearance at the Hearts and Minds conference.
November 9, 2023
Tom Naughton - There's money in mi goreng | Prusik Investment

A true contrarian investor, Chris Kourtis can find himself sounding a lot like a bull when in the company of bears, and there’s a lot to be bearish about at the moment.
November 6, 2023
Why Chris Kourtis just bought CSL and ResMed

As soon as the three musketeers [Guy Fowler, Matthew Grounds and Gary Weiss] spoke to me I said ‘stop’. They said ‘we haven’t finished’. And I said, ‘I’m in’. We invested $10 million in Sohn Hearts and Minds. So substantial enough for a young fellow like me.
November 3, 2023
Paradice and Lew on their love of medical research – and Greece

Famed hedge fund manager Dan Loeb has been named as one of the headline acts for next month’s Sohn Hearts & Minds philanthropic investment conference to be held in Sydney. Mr Loeb, 61, has built a reputation as a fierce shareholder activist and oversees $US11.7 billion ($18.5 billion) at New York-based Third Point.
October 23, 2023
Dan Loeb to headline Sohn Hearts & Minds

Bryce and Ren from Equity Mates are joined by Rikki Bannan, Executive Director and Portfolio Manager at IFM Investors.
October 18, 2023
Rikki Bannan - Two small caps: Propel Funeral Services (ASX: PFP) and Clarity Pharmaceuticals (ASX: CU6)

Last year, Ravi Chopra was travelling through Europe to shop his latest short idea to potential investors. "Financials are really all in the weeds," Ravi Chopra shared with The Australian Financial Review. "It’s all about numbers, it’s about modeling. It’s not just about looking at earnings reports, but also diving into regulatory data.
October 16, 2023
How this hedge fund pulled off 2023’s ‘big short’

“Healthcare is often viewed as a stable, defensive sector to invest in, but in small caps that hasn’t necessarily proven to be the case,” she says in an interview with The Australian ahead of her appearance as a stock tipper at the Sohn Hearts & Minds conference in Sydney next month.
October 10, 2023
Beware the pitfalls of investing in healthcare, says IFM boss

According to Dr Attia - who will speak at the Sohn Hearts & Minds in Sydney next month - nothing is completely random. He has built a career unearthing about what fuels a long life and shared his knowledge in the bestselling book Outlive: The Science & Art of Longevity.
October 6, 2023
Secret to a long life cheaper than you think celebrity physician Peter Attia reveals

Angela Aldrich bet against Treasury Wine Estates at the top of the market; now the Bayberry Capital founder is preparing to make her next big call.
September 18, 2023
‘Volatility is opportunity’: why this manager loves shorting stocks

Influential New York hedge fund manager Ricky Sandler says no one is focused on picking interesting, idiosyncratic stocks.
September 11, 2023
Stock stars look under the surface

When New York-based hedge fund manager Ricky Sandler arrived in Australia a year ago to spend time with his son who was studying in Sydney, he didn’t expect to become the reigning champion of a philanthropic investor conference.
September 11, 2023
Top NY stock picker warns inflation to remain above pre-COVID levels

After a decade of easy money pushing equity markets in one direction, Wall Street hedge fund manager Ricky Sandler says the return of volatility and higher interest rates is seeing money return to long-short strategies.
September 11, 2023
Investors sweeten on hedge funds as rates climb